14 years one-stop China custom CNC machining parts factory
Hey there I’m VMT Sam!
With 25 years of CNC machining experience we are committed to helping clients overcome 10000 complex part-processing challenges all to contribute to a better life through intelligent manufacturing. Contact us now
109 |
Published by VMT at Jul 20 2024
Overview
In the field of CNC machining parts manufacturing, cast aluminum and forged aluminum are two primary forms of aluminum materials, each with unique characteristics and application scenarios. Cast aluminum is obtained through casting processes, making it suitable for mass production of complex-shaped parts; forged aluminum, processed through forging, boasts higher strength and toughness, ideal for demanding performance requirements. This article provides an in-depth comparison of cast aluminum and forged aluminum from multiple dimensions, helping readers better understand their differences and make informed choices in practical applications.
Cast Aluminum Alloys
Cast aluminum alloys are aluminum-based materials produced through casting processes. These alloys typically contain elements such as silicon, copper, magnesium, and zinc to enhance their physical and chemical properties. Due to their excellent fluidity and castability, cast aluminum alloys can produce parts with complex shapes and precise dimensions, widely used in automotive, aerospace, and machinery manufacturing sectors.
Characteristics of Cast Aluminum
Cast aluminum has a range of unique properties, including lightweight and high strength, good corrosion resistance, excellent castability, and machinability. Its lightweight nature helps reduce overall product weight and improve energy efficiency; corrosion resistance allows it to maintain stable performance in harsh environments; castability enables the easy realization of complex shapes; and machinability permits further CNC processing to meet high precision requirements.
Production of Cast Aluminum Alloys
The production of cast aluminum alloys involves several stages, including melting, casting, cooling, and finishing. Initially, aluminum ingots and alloy elements are mixed proportionally and heated to a molten state in a furnace. The molten metal is then poured into pre-designed molds, where it solidifies into castings upon cooling. Finally, the castings undergo cleaning, trimming, and other post-processing steps to meet usage requirements.
| Grade | Composition (wt%) | Tensile Strength (MPa) | Yield Strength (MPa) 0.2% |
| 1xx.x | 99.00% to 99.99% aluminium | 131 – 448 | 28 – 152 |
| 2xx.x | 4% to 4.6% Copper | 131 – 276 | 90 – 345 |
| 3xx.x | 5% to 17% Silicon | 117 – 172 | 66 – 172 |
| 4xx.x | 5% to 12% Silicon | 117 – 172 | 41 – 48 |
| 5xx.x | 5% to 12% Magnesium | 131 – 448 | 62 – 152 |
| 6xx.x | Not Used | ||
| 7xx.x | 6.2% to 7.5% Zinc | 207 – 379 | 117 – 310 |
Applications of Cast Aluminum Alloys
Thanks to their superior performance, cast aluminum alloys find applications across various industries. In the automotive industry, cast aluminum parts are used for critical components such as engine blocks and transmission housings; in the aerospace sector, they are employed in manufacturing aircraft engine parts and structural components. Additionally, cast aluminum alloys are extensively used in machinery manufacturing, architectural decoration, and more.
Advantages of Cast Aluminum Alloys
The main advantages of cast aluminum alloys include cost efficiency, high material utilization, complex shape capability, and strong recyclability. In mass production, casting processes can significantly lower production costs; optimized designs can reduce material waste; casting can create complex shapes that other processes may struggle to achieve; and the recyclability of aluminum helps reduce resource waste and environmental pollution.
Forged Aluminum
Forged aluminum refers to aluminum and aluminum alloy materials processed through forging. During forging, aluminum undergoes plastic deformation under pressure to achieve the desired shape and size. Forged aluminum parts usually exhibit higher strength and toughness, along with excellent fatigue resistance and impact performance.
Performance of Forged Aluminum
The performance characteristics of forged aluminum include high strength, high toughness, good fatigue resistance, and impact resistance. The forging process results in a denser and more continuous fiber structure, enhancing the material's strength and toughness. Additionally, the residual compressive stress generated during forging contributes to improved fatigue life and impact toughness.
| Grade | Composition | Tensile Strength (MPa) | Yield Strength (MPa) 0.2% |
| 1000 Series | 99.00% to 99.99% aluminium | 82 – 166 | 28 – 152 |
| 2000 Series | 2.2% to 6.8% copper | 186 – 467 | 76 – 345 |
| 3000 Series | 0.3% to 1.5% manganese | 110 – 283 | 41 – 248 |
| 4000 Series |
3.6% to 13.5% silicon 0.1% to 4.7% copper 0.05% to 1.3% magnesium |
172 – 414 | 45 - 180 |
| 5000 Series | 0.5% to 5.5% Magnesium | 124 – 352 | 41 - 345 |
| 6000 Series |
0.2% to 1.8% silicon 0.35% to 1.5% magnesium |
124 – 310.3 | 55.2 – 276 |
| 7000 Series |
0.8% to 8.2% zinc 0.1% to 3.4% magnesium 0.05% to 2.6% copper |
228 – 572 | 103 - 503 |
Production of Forged Aluminum Alloys
The production of forged aluminum alloys involves heating, forging, cooling, and finishing steps. First, aluminum is heated to an appropriate temperature to soften its structure and increase its plasticity. The heated aluminum is then subjected to pressure in a forging machine to achieve the desired shape. After forging, the material undergoes cooling to stabilize its structure and properties. Finally, the forged parts are trimmed and surface treated to meet usage requirements.
Applications of Forged Aluminum Alloys
Due to their excellent mechanical and processing properties, forged aluminum materials are widely used in high-performance demanding fields. In the aerospace industry, forged aluminum parts are used for critical components such as aircraft landing gear and engine blades. In the automotive industry, they are used for manufacturing wheels, suspension systems, and other parts. Additionally, forged aluminum finds applications in military equipment, nuclear energy, and other sectors.
Advantages of Forged Aluminum Alloys
The advantages of forged aluminum alloys lie in their high strength and toughness, precise control over dimensions and shapes, and optimized material properties. The forging process significantly enhances the material's strength and toughness, as well as fatigue and impact resistance. Precise control during forging ensures dimensional and shape accuracy of the parts, and the process improves the material's structure and properties, enhancing overall performance and lifespan.
Choosing between cast aluminum and forged aluminum requires considering multiple factors for a well-informed decision. Here is a specific analysis of each factor:
Chemical Composition: Choose the appropriate alloy composition based on the part's operating environment and performance requirements. Different alloying elements significantly impact the mechanical properties and corrosion resistance of aluminum materials.
Manufacturing Process: Consider production volume, shape complexity, and production cycle when selecting the appropriate manufacturing process. Casting is suitable for mass production of complex-shaped parts, while forging is better for small-batch production or parts with stringent performance requirements.
Mechanical Properties: Evaluate the required strength, toughness, and hardness to determine the suitable material type. Forged aluminum typically offers higher strength and toughness but comes at a higher cost, while cast aluminum offers lower cost but slightly lesser mechanical properties.
Load Capacity: Consider the maximum load the part will bear during operation. For high-load parts, forged aluminum's superior strength and toughness may be more suitable.
Durability: Assess the part's lifespan and maintenance costs. In harsh environments or high-stress conditions, forged aluminum's durability may outperform cast aluminum.
Cost: Consider material cost, processing cost, and maintenance cost comprehensively. Cast aluminum is cost-effective for mass production, while forged aluminum, with its complex process and lower material utilization, is relatively more expensive.
Surface Treatment: Choose the appropriate surface treatment method based on appearance requirements and corrosion resistance needs. Both cast and forged aluminum can undergo anodizing, painting, and other surface treatments to enhance corrosion resistance and aesthetics.
Design Flexibility: Consider the complexity and freedom of part design. Casting allows for complex shapes, offering higher design flexibility, while forging suits simpler shapes requiring high precision.
Strength: Emphasize the importance of strength as a crucial factor in material selection. For parts needing to withstand high stress, forged aluminum's high strength is advantageous.
Production Volume: Choose the appropriate material based on production needs. For mass production, cast aluminum's cost-effectiveness may be more attractive, while for small-batch or custom production, forged aluminum's flexibility and high performance may be more appealing.
Complexity of Shapes: For parts with complex shapes that are difficult to achieve through other processes, casting might be a better choice. Cast aluminum easily produces complex shapes, meeting diverse design needs.
Porosity: Cast aluminum parts may have porosity and other casting defects that affect performance. Therefore, it's essential to consider the porosity situation and take appropriate measures to reduce porosity to improve part performance.
| Features | Forged Aluminum | Cast Aluminum |
| Chemical Composition | Al-Si-Mg-Cu alloy and Al-Cu-Ni-Fe alloy | Al-Si series, Al-Cu series, Al-Mg series, and Al-Zn series |
| Structural Integrity | Far superior in strength | More porous and prone to breakage |
| Durability | Excellent | High |
| Tolerance | Not suitable for complex shapes | Can achieve a high level of detail and tight tolerances |
| Product Size | Limited in size and thickness capabilities (larger sizes are more challenging) | Compatible with various sizes |
| Secondary Operations | Usually requires additional operations to refine and finish the product | Provides finished product that requires minimal post processing |
| Cost | More cost-effective for medium to large production runs | Generally less expensive than forging, but it depends on the specific casting method used |
| Strength | Higher | Lower |
| Design Flexibility | Low to Moderate | High |
| Cost | Higher | Lower (especially in high volume) |
| Production Volume | Best for Low to Medium Volume | Ideal for High Volume |
| Surface Finish | Rougher, may require post-processing | Smooth, requires less post-processing |
| Durability | High | Moderate |
| Complexity of Shape | Low to Moderate | High |
| Porosity | Minimal | Possible |
In summary, cast aluminum and forged aluminum each have their strengths in the CNC machining parts manufacturing field. Cast aluminum, with its low cost, excellent castability, and machinability, is suitable for mass production of complex-shaped parts. Forged aluminum, with its high strength, high toughness, and precise dimensional control, holds a significant position in high-performance demanding areas. When choosing, consider the specific application scenario, performance requirements, and economic factors to select the most suitable material type.
As experts in CNC machining parts manufacturing, VMT possesses rich experience and advanced technical capabilities, offering customized machining or casting solutions for clients. Whether you need cast aluminum or forged aluminum CNC machined parts, VMT can provide professional consultation and services tailored to your specific needs. We have advanced CNC machining equipment and a professional technical team to ensure the machining precision and performance of the parts meet your requirements. Additionally, we offer one-stop solutions including CNC prototype machining and CNC machining services to support the successful implementation of your projects.
Is forging better than casting?
Forging and casting each have their advantages; there is no absolute superiority. The choice depends on the specific application scenario and performance requirements.
What is the difference between aluminum and cast aluminum?
Aluminum is a metal element, while cast aluminum refers to aluminum-based alloy materials produced through casting. Cast aluminum is an important application form of aluminum, characterized by light weight, corrosion resistance, and machinability.
Which is more expensive, cast aluminum or forged aluminum?
Generally, forged aluminum is more expensive than cast aluminum due to the complexity of the forging process, lower material utilization, and higher equipment requirements, leading to increased production costs.
Are OEM wheels cast or forged?
OEM wheels can be either cast or forged, depending on the vehicle manufacturer's design requirements and cost considerations. Cast wheels are cost-effective but may offer slightly lower performance than forged wheels, which have higher strength and toughness but are more expensive.
Which has more defects, castings or forgings?
Both castings and forgings can have defects, but the type and quantity of defects depend on various factors. Castings may have porosity and shrinkage defects affecting performance, while forgings can have forging cracks and folds affecting quality. Therefore, it's essential to analyze specific situations rather than generalize which has more defects.
+86 15099911516
Read more
